U.S. Supreme Court Overturns Roe v. Wade

By John Lavenburg

PROSPECT HEIGHTS — Decades of prayers from pro-life advocates were answered this morning as the Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade, and in doing so abolished the legal right to an abortion at the federal level, and returned the jurisdiction back to state lawmakers. 

[READ THE FULL OPINION HERE]

The Supreme Court’s decision came in a ruling on the case Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization, which dealt with the constitutionality of Mississippi’s 15-week abortion ban. Roe — the landmark 1973 decision that legalized abortion nationwide — held that abortion was legal up to the point of viability (when a baby can survive outside of the womb), which is typically considered to be 24 weeks. 

The 6 to 3 majority opinion was written by Justice Samuel Alito. He was joined by Justices Clarence Thomas, Neil Gorsuch, Brett Kavanaugh and Amy Coney Barrett. 

Chief Justice John Roberts voted with the majority, but wrote a separate opinion.  

“We hold that Roe and [Planned Parenthood v. Casey] must be overruled,” Alito wrote. “The constitution makes no reference to abortion, and no such right is implicitly protected by any constitutional provision.” 

Justices  Stephen Breyer, Sonia Sotomayor and Elena Kagan wrote the dissenting opinion, stating that regardless of the scope of the state laws that will follow this decision, “one result of today’s decision is certain: the curtailment of women’s rights and their status as free and equal citizens.” 

The Dobbs ruling brings to a close months of anticipation from people on both sides of the abortion debate. Pro-life advocates hoped for this decision after a draft opinion of the case leaked on May 3 showing as much. 

The U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishop’s Committee on Pro-Life Activities, issued the following statement:

“This is a historic day in the life of our country, one that stirs our thoughts, emotions and prayers,” the statement said. “For nearly fifty years, America has enforced an unjust law that has permitted some to decide whether others can live or die; this policy has resulted in the deaths of tens of millions of preborn children, generations that were denied the right to even be born.”

Meanwhile, pro-abortion advocates feared what the ruling would mean in states that planned to restrict abortion access. 

Now that the Dobbs decision has been made, and state lawmakers control abortion laws, there will likely be a flurry of actions from both pro-life and pro-abortion-leaning state governments that will either tighten or loosen abortion access in their state. 

Currently, 13 states — Arkansas, Idaho, Kentucky, Louisiana, Mississippi, Missouri, North Dakota, Oklahoma, South Dakota, Tennessee, Texas, Utah, and Wyoming — have “trigger” laws that, with Roe overturned, immediately or almost immediately go into effect and ban abortion. 

Five other states — Alabama, Arizona, Michigan, West Virginia, and Wisconsin — have pre-Roe abortion bans still on the books that will also go into effect. However, lawmakers in Wisconsin have signaled there will be a contentious battle over enforcing the law, and a Michigan claims court granted a motion that blocks the state’s attorney general from enforcing the law. 

On the other side, 13 states — Colorado, Connecticut Delaware, Hawaii, Illinois, Massachusetts, Nevada, New Jersey, Oregon, Rhode Island, Vermont, Virginia, and Washington — have already codified the right to an abortion into state law at varying stages of pregnancy. For them, the Dobbs ruling has little impact. Four of those states — New Jersey, Oregon, Vermont, and Colorado —  have codified the right to an abortion throughout the entire pregnancy. 

In New York, per the 2019 Reproductive Health Act, abortion is legal up to 24 weeks of pregnancy, or when “there is an absence of fetal viability, or the abortion is necessary to protect the patient’s life or health.” However, the law does not define “health” or “fetal viability” and stipulates that the determination of these factors must be made by a healthcare practitioner. The state’s Catholic bishops, therefore, argue that abortion is legal through nine months of pregnancy. 

Ever since the leaked draft of the Dobbs opinion Gov. Kathy Hochul has taken steps to ensure that abortion access is available in the Empire State to New Yorkers and out-of-staters alike. Earlier this week after signing a flurry of abortion rights legislation, Hochul reiterated her belief that “reproductive rights are human rights.” 

“The women of New York will never be subjected to government-mandated pregnancies,” Hochul said in a statement. ”Not here. Not now. Not ever.”

 

Catholic News Headlines for Thursday, 06/23/22

The country is bracing for the Supreme Court to possibly strike down Roe v Wade as soon as Friday.

The Supreme Court on Thursday shot down a New York gun law that placed restrictions on carrying a concealed firearm outside the home.

The MTA has put hidden cameras on 65 train cars in the past 6 weeks.

SCOTUS Decision Marks Widest Expansion of Gun Rights in a Decade

It’s the largest expansion of gun rights in a decade.

The Supreme Court on Thursday shot down a New York gun law that placed restrictions on carrying a concealed firearm outside the home.

That verdict comes as the country continues to battle gun violence.

Catholic Schools Night Draws Huge Crowd To Honor Young Scholars and Watch Priests vs. Principals Game

By Bill Miller

CONEY ISLAND — It would have taken more than a little rain to wash out Catholic Schools Night — and the “Collars vs. Scholars” diamond tilt — at Maimonides Park on Tuesday evening, June 21.

The event honored an estimated 60 valedictorians and salutatorians from the Catholic academies and parish schools in the Diocese of Brooklyn. The “vals and sals” received commemorative medals for their academic achievements.

“They are a credit to their schools,” said Bishop Robert Brennan. “And I am glad they came out tonight so that we could show them appreciation.”

And yes, there was a minor league baseball game on tap, pitting the hometown Brooklyn Cyclones against the Jersey Shore BlueClaws. That gave Bishop Brennan a chance to make his first visit to Maimonides Park to watch the Cyclones, a minor-league affiliate of the New York Mets — his favorite team since his youth.

Hundreds of kids and their families ignored the wet weather to turn out for the event, which featured the distribution of free bobbleheads of Msgr. David Cassato, vicar for Catholic schools for the Diocese of Brooklyn, who recently announced his retirement as pastor of St. Athanasius parish in Bensonhurst.

Msgr. Cassato was all over the park Tuesday evening.

He threw out one of the game’s first pitches and presided over the pre-game softball match between diocesan priests, the “Collars” wearing black jerseys, and the “Scholars” — Catholic school principals, teachers, and school administrators, in white.

Msgr. Cassato started out wearing the Collars jersey, but later switched to a white Cyclones’ jersey with red lettering. He’ll remain busy as vicar for Catholic schools, and in his role as Deputy Chief Chaplain of the New York Police Department.

Catholic Schools Night was sponsored by the diocese and DeSales Media Group.Tom Chadzutko, who recently announced his retirement as superintendent of schools for the diocese, attended the game. Also on hand was Chadzutko’s incoming successor — Deacon Kevin McCormack, currently the principal of Xaverian High School in Bay Ridge.

“Tonight is a terrific night because it gets everybody together for a good time,” said Deacon McCormack, who starts his new job on July 1. “We celebrate the scholars because they’re the top kids in our schools, but they represent so many other great kids.”

Joe Venticinque, principal at Our Lady of Snows Catholic Academy in Floral Park, said he had “a blast.” He scored two runs in the Scholars’ 9-6 victory over the Collars.

“It was just a good night to get together, celebrate Catholic education, and have fun doing it,” he said. “I got to see colleagues that I haven’t seen in a couple of years because of COVID. It really is one of our biggest events in the last couple of years.”

Students also celebrated Catholic Schools Night, which was sponsored by the diocese and DeSales Media Group.

“It felt good representing our school,” said Joseph Kearney, who enters the 7th grade this fall at St. Bernard Catholic Academy in Mill Basin.

His 4th-grade-bound sister, Mia, said she didn’t know much about baseball, but she was grateful for her school, saying, “We get to learn about Jesus and the Catholic rites.”

Said her brother: “I just like learning about God.”

Pope Asks Families to Take a Small Step Toward Greater Holiness

By Cindy Wooden

VATICAN CITY (CNS) — The Catholic Church professes marriage and family life to be a path to holiness — a daunting concept — but one that can start with a tiny step, Pope Francis said.

“Start from where you are, and, from there, try to journey together: together as couples, together in your families, together with other families, together with the church,” the pope said June 22, opening the World Meeting of Families with an evening “Festival of Families” in the Vatican audience hall.

The in-presence portion of most of the event June 22-26 was limited to about 2,000 people — official delegates of bishops’ conferences, Catholic family associations and movements. But the entire event was being livestreamed, and parishes and dioceses around the world were holding their own events at the same time on the theme, “Family love: a vocation and a path to holiness.”

At the opening festival, with some 4,500 people in the Vatican audience hall, Pope Francis said he wanted the church to be a “good Samaritan that draws near to you and helps you to continue your journey and to take a step forward, however small.”

Cardinal Kevin J. Farrell, prefect of the Dicastery for Laity, the Family and Life, welcomed delegates to the gathering and told Pope Francis the five families — from Rome, Ukraine and Congo — that shared their stories “are not perfect families … because, as you always say, perfect don’t exist.”

“They are normal families who, like so many others, in every country and latitude, go through the difficulties and sufferings typical of our time,” the cardinal said, but they have discovered that when the problems are experienced with faith, they can open “incredible paths of family holiness.”

Serena Zangla and Luigi Franco, who have lived together for 10 years and have three children, spoke to the pope of the difficulty they had in finding a parish that would accept and support them, for which Pope Francis apologized. Zangla said they finally have found a community and are hoping to be married soon.

The sacrament of marriage is the gift God gives to couples in love, the pope said. “It is a marvelous gift, which contains the power of God’s own love: strong, enduring, faithful, ready to start over after every failure or moment of weakness.”

“Family life is not ‘mission impossible,'” he told them. “By the grace of the sacrament, God makes it a wonderful journey, to be undertaken together with him and never alone.”

Roberto and Maria Anselma Corbella shared with the crowd the story of the illness and death of their daughter, Chiara, who eventually chose not to pursue cancer treatment so her unborn baby would live.

“To see how she experienced the trial of her illness helped you to lift up your gaze, not to remain imprisoned in grief, but to be open to something greater: the mysterious plans of God, to eternity, to heaven,” the pope said. “I thank you for this witness of faith!”

Paul and Germaine Balenza of Congo spoke of the crises in their marriage, including infidelity, and how members of the Christian Family Community helped them find the strength to forgive and begin again.

“No one wants a love that is short-term or is marked with an expiration date,” the pope said. “We suffer greatly whenever failings, negligence and human sins make a shipwreck of marriage. But even amid the tempest, God sees what is in our hearts.”

Listening to their story, the pope said he was reminded of the biblical story of the prodigal son, “only this time, the ones who went astray were the parents, not the child!”

Pope Francis congratulated the couple for celebrating a “feast of forgiveness” with their children and renewing their wedding vows at Mass, because it helped their children see “the humility needed to beg forgiveness and the God-given strength to pick yourselves up after the fall.”

Iryna Kozhushko and her daughter Sofia from Ukraine, and Pietro and Erika Chiriaco, the couple with six young children hosting them in Acilia, a suburb of Rome, also shared their stories.

The welcome offered by the Chiriaco family, Pope Francis said, shows the generosity that almost naturally comes from having a large family where people are “trained to make room for others.”

“In the end, this is what family is all about. In the family, we experience what it is to be welcomed. Husbands and wives are the first to ‘welcome’ and accept one another, as they said they would do on the day of their marriage,” he said. “Later, as they bring a child into the world, they welcome that new life.”

“Whereas in cold and anonymous situations, the weak are often rejected,” the pope said, “in families it is natural to welcome them: to accept a child with a disability, an elderly person in need of care, a family member in difficulty who has no one else — this gives hope.”

Zakia Seddiki, a Moroccan Muslim and widow of Luca Attanasio, the Italian ambassador to Congo killed in an ambush in 2021 at the age of 43, also spoke at the event.

Seddiki had told the crowd, “We based our family on authentic love, with respect, solidarity and dialogue between our cultures.”

“None of that was lost, not even after the tragedy of Luca’s death,” the pope said. “Not only do the example and the spiritual legacy of Luca continue to live on and to speak to the consciences of many people, but also the organization that Zakia founded in some way carries on his mission. Indeed, we can say that Luca’s diplomatic mission has now become ‘a mission of peace’ on the part of your entire family.”

Pope Francis praised Seddiki and Attanasio for supporting and respecting each other’s religious identities and focusing on how both Islam and Christianity called them to work “to overcome divisions, prejudices and narrow-mindedness, and to build together something grand, something beautiful, on the basis of what we have in common.”

Catholic News Headlines for Wednesday, 06/22/22

After a two-year hiatus because of COVID, it was the long-anticipated rematch between diocesan clergy and school employees.

The investigation into the response by the Uvalde Police Department to the elementary school shooting is intensifying.

The 10th World Meeting of Families kicked off in Rome Wednesday.

Foundation Builds Ramps to Carry On FF Klein’s Legacy of Service

By Paula Katinas

BELLE HARBOR — Firefighter Timothy Klein’s FDNY buddies will readily tell you that he loved nothing more than helping people in need.

A talented carpenter, Klein was an active member of The Fight for Firefighters Foundation, a group specializing in constructing ramps at homes of first responders to give their wheelchair-bound relatives easier mobility.

Klein, 31, who was assigned to Ladder 170 in Canarsie, died while battling a fire in that community in April. His friends in the foundation, who are mostly FDNY members, are still grieving the loss of their colleague and pal.

But on June 21, they put their grief aside to get back to the task of building ramps — seeing it as a way of carrying on his legacy.

So, bright and early Tuesday morning, they were at a house on Beach 140th Street in Belle Harbor constructing a ramp for 79-year-old Paula Antonio, a stroke victim who was left paralyzed on her left side. She is still recovering in a nursing home and is expected to return home in early July.

“We’re doing this for Timmy. This is our first build since he died,” Foundation President John Vaeth said.

It was a large crew, numbering about 20 foundation members. Wearing bright orange T-shirts with the group’s name, they worked in teams — some measuring and cutting wood for the foundation that would hold the ramp in place, while others carefully put together the sections of the metal ramp itself.

The ramp project was also dedicated to the memory of another deceased FDNY member — Firefighter Steven Pollard, 31, a fellow member of Ladder 170 who died in 2019 when he fell from the Mill Basin Bridge while responding to a two-car crash.

Klein delivered the eulogy at Pollard’s funeral, calling his friend “a kind, respectful and dedicated fireman” and “a quiet person who never uttered any ill words towards anyone.”

Once the ramp was completed Tuesday, the foundation planned to present a plaque bearing the names of Klein and Pollard to the Antonio Family.

Klein was totally dedicated to The Fight for Firefighters Foundation, as well as a board member, Vaeth said.

“If Timmy was here with us, he’d be getting right to work, sawing wood, drilling, lifting stuff,” he explained. “He helped a lot with the builds and he helped a real lot before the builds — talking to people and getting money for all this stuff. It was so much work. It was unbelievable.”

Klein’s father, retired FDNY Firefighter Patrick Klein, was there to lend a hand. “It carries on with what he really had a passion for — which was helping people,” he said. “This is something that he got into when he was early on the job and each year, he got more and more involved.

He didn’t even tell us (his family) half the things he was doing. We found out later all the things he was involved in,” Patrick Klein added.

The foundation found out about Paula Antonio through a friend in the neighborhood and offered to build the ramp for her. There is an FDNY connection: her grandson, Patrick Lonie, is an Emergency Medical Technician.

Her son E.J. Antonio watched as the work progressed. “These guys are wonderful, and  pretty efficient. They showed up, I showed them where the power outlets were and they got right to work,” he said.

The ramp will mean a great deal, he added. “This is my mom’s house. Unfortunately, she’s had other complications with the stroke and she requires 24-hour care. So we’re going to bring her home to a very comfortable place that she lives in so she can sit on the porch and enjoy life.”

Now that the foundation is back to constructing ramps, the plan is to continue, Vaeth said. “We’re going to be doing at least one build each month,” he explained.

For information on how to donate to The Fight For Firefighters Foundation, vist the group’s website: https://www.fightforfirefightersfoundation.com/home and click the Donate button.